The Parliamentary Office for Evaluation of science and technology has delivered a very strange report information on pesticides and health. Claude Gatignol signed by the member and Senator Jean-Claude Etienne, he scores a comeback for the promotion of agriculture in thrall to the chemical industry.
And it ignores the preservation of ecosystems, water resources and soil, the quality of food, income and health of farmers.
When the vote of this text, there were only 10 MPs out of 36. I am the only one who voted against it. I give you my thoughts here after laminated with the attendance report, the parliamentarians have discovered that the day of presentation.
Coincidentally, just before the Grenelle 2
Filed on the table a week before the Grenelle 2 to Assembly National, he participated in flashback with the consideration of the environment is the victim in recent months.
His subject, pesticides, is addressed by the juxtaposition of hearings, and conflicting opinions.
But the warnings of scientists about the possible risks of these products are not taken into account. Uncertainty, when it is put forward, is always to the benefit of themselves.
The tone is set right from the introduction:
"Agriculture has been built around the use of plant protection products, means of plant products offer quality and appearance flawless as expected by the consumer. "
Bees are not endangered
The report is full of interim findings to the ambiguous wording. For example, it is written:
"In France, national statistics do not allow to date to quantify precisely a phenomenon of excess mortality affecting apiaries in the country. "Certainly
. But as written, without any conclusion from the dead bees and beekeepers' grievances, the reader can deduce that there is no visible bloodshed.
The publication is a Trojan horse to devices agriculture major groups. Agriculture called "rational" is promoted as a model, even though everyone knows it is based on a minimum commitments, which would amount to a motorist to certify that it will not burn red lights and stop it to stop.
careful not to fall too sharply pesticides
Twenty pages of GMOs as an alternative, although their implementation supports the use of pesticides associated, such as grain "Roundup Ready" or they secrete themselves insecticides.
The tone is set:
"The commitment Grenelle of the environment to reduce pesticide use by 50% within ten years would imply, according to a simulation that any French agriculture switches integrated. "
But if this goal was met, here are the threats outlined by the report: lower yields, malnutrition in the world, rising agricultural prices, pest resistance, negative signal for the research, loss of production of fruits and vegetables ...
Reporters' remind the benefits of pesticide use and invite the government to anticipate the consequences of a too sharp decrease in the use Pesticides in France. "
The role of carcinogenic pesticides is reduced
All this makes the field for the majority of the amendments, which provide conditioning to reduce these substances to an assessment of potential economic effects. After
minus the comparative quality of organic food and a food laden with pesticides, and the role carcinogenic pesticides, the report mentions all other sources of endocrine disrupting pesticides for better clearance.
As for occupational diseases farmers proved a timely picture of their exposures Daily arrow other sources of pathology: the fuel for their tractors, smoke, dust field, and even the UV, they work outdoors.
And if a household exposure study showed an excess of brain tumors, the rapporteurs conclude:
"But this result is to take all precautions especially as the question" Treat Do you have houseplants? "Was not specific enough and that people may well have answered in the affirmative, they use insecticides, fertilizers, or they do shine as watering their plants. "
Obviously, when you do not want to hear, you will not hear!
Yet, as noted by the Environmental Health Network, "the health impact of pesticides is found, just read the scientific literature on a non-selective. "
Recommendations were probably much more informed by the doctor that the veterinarian Stephen Gatignol. They support the work and have many more interesting features, such as increasing research in toxicology or cancer registries.
But they conceal the attempts of deregulation, guilt Beekeepers-which was not accepted my proposal to involve them in research protocols, or the promotion of GMOs.
0 comments:
Post a Comment